Talk:Stewards/Confirm/2017

Latest comment: 6 years ago by Ajraddatz in topic Final decisions (by stewards)

End time? edit

Per Stewards/Elections 2017 I expect this will remain open till 28 February 2017, 13:59 (UTC), too? Want to vote but need the time. --.js[democracy needed] 18:35, 27 February 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]

Yes, it will close at the same time as the steward elections. – Ajraddatz (talk) 18:39, 27 February 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]

How long will the process for discussion confirmations take? Or is there an open end for that? --Bjarlin (talk) 15:44, 13 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]

Looking at Template:Steward confirmations, I'm reading there:

  • "Confirmation discussions will last one week after the appointment of the newly elected stewards. This may be extended to two weeks for one or more confirmations at the discretion of the Election Committee if the committee believes further input is required before concluding."

Thus, confirmation discussions seem to have begun on 5 March 2017, that's more than a week ago now. Why aren't the clear-cut cases closed? Then it would be possible to see which are the closer cases which still are under discussion. --Bjarlin (talk) 15:53, 13 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]

Final decisions (by stewards) edit

The summaries below only provide a convenient overview. Stewards should review the actual confirmation comments and their understanding of relevant policies before commenting.

Confirmation discussions will last one week after the appointment of the newly elected stewards. This may be extended to two weeks for one or more confirmations at the discretion of the Election Committee if the committee believes further input is required before concluding. The Election Committee will close these discussions and implement the outcome (which also means making a decision in non-obvious cases).

This section is for steward discussion only. Please do not comment in this box unless you are a steward.

Each discussion below starts with a summary of the confirmation comments. Coloured and underlined names have notes attached; move your cursor onto the names to show the notes, or refer to this legend:

  • Agrees with this point, but favours confirmation.
  • Agrees with this point, but opposes confirmation.
  • Agrees with this point, but is undecided about confirmation.
Status Candidate Notes
   Confirmed
Ajraddatz Clear consensus to confirm
   Confirmed
Avraham Weak consensus to confirm
   Resigned
Barras Removal per his request
   Removed
Bennylin Consensus to remove
   Confirmed
Bsadowski1 Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
DerHexer Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Einsbor Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Hoo man Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Jyothis Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Linedwell Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
MBisanz Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
MF-Warburg Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
MarcoAurelio Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Mardetanha Clear consensus to confirm
   Confirmed
Masti Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Matanya Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Melos Weak consensus to confirm
   Confirmed
Mentifisto Consensus to confirm
   Confirmed
NahidSultan Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Pmlineditor Weak consensus to confirm
   Confirmed
QuiteUnusual Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
RadiX Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Ruslik0 Consensus to confirm
   Confirmed
Savh Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Shanmugamp7 Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Stryn Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Tegel Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Teles Nihil obstat
   Confirmed
Trijnstel Clear consensus to confirm
   Confirmed
Vituzzu Clear consensus to confirm
Ajraddatz (talk) 19:11, 13 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]

Ajraddatz edit

105 users commented on Ajraddatz' confirmation. Final revision r16366957.

Favourable
  • no reason given
76 agreed (29 didn't mention this).
Shivanarayana, Vituzzu, GZWDer, Murma174, Yeza, Juandev, Juliancolton, Fastily, StevenJ81, Bookvaedina, Rax, DCB, MechQuester, Bjarlin, TheGeneralUser, Marshallsumter, 小躍, Widr, MoiraMoira, Udo T., Leon saudanha, CreativeC38, Samuele2002, Ankry, Krd, Matanya, Coffins, Thogo, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Wagino 20100516, Elmie, Holder, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, YaganZ, Richardkiwi, JustBerry, AryanSogd, Natuur12, AFBorchert, Melos, TyA, Calak, Meno25, Matěj Suchánek, TJH2018, cyfraw, İncelemeelemani, Barras, Itay17, Zyephyrus, Hanay, Itti, Rxy, Quiddity, Uğurkent, Masti, Mifter, Xaosflux, Jusjih, Geagea, Rzuwig, Stang, MarcoAurelio, KlaasZ4usV, MisterSynergy, Ping08, Alan, Jmvkrecords, AlvaroMolina, -revi, DoRD, TBloemink, Teles
  • good steward / good work / high activity / no concerns etc.
26 agreed (79 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Vogone, Steinsplitter, Jianhui67, Ah3kal, Ks-M9, Liuxinyu970226, Cameron11598, Chansey, Linedwell, Atcovi, Iazyges, Pokéfan95, NickK, Syum90, Laurent Jerry, Billinghurst, Lepricavark, Kurtis, Shanmugamp7, Biplab Anand, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, NahidSultan, Savh
Concerned
  • no confidence
2 agreed (103 didn't mention this).
Slowking4, Шухрат Саъдиев

  • 1 neutral "comment".

Avraham edit

84 users commented on Avraham's confirmation. Final revision r16367677.

Favourable
  • no reason given
30 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu, GZWDer, Bookvaedina, Rax, -jkb-, Bjarlin, Jusjih, Leon saudanha, Chansey, Samuele2002, Matanya, Thogo, Howan Hansi, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, AryanSogd, AFBorchert, Melos, Hardenacke, cyfraw, Juliancolton, Barras, Eraevsky, Zyephyrus, Quiddity, Masti, Mifter, Pmlineditor, Ultraexactzz, Geagea
  • Active enough, occasionally active & reasonable actions
4 agreed (80 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Lepricavark, Kurtis, Miniapolis
  • No reason to remove / good to go etc.
5 agreed (79 didn't mention this).
Ks-M9, Liuxinyu970226, NickK, Lankiveil, AlvaroMolina
  • Important work behind the scenes
5 agreed, 1 seconded (78 didn't mention this).
StevenJ81, This, that and the other, NickK, MarcoAurelio[Teles], Snowolf
  • experienced / competent / sensible
5 agreed, 1 seconded (78 didn't mention this).
DoRD[Jmvkrecords], NickK, Lankiveil, Billinghurst, RadiX
  • trusted
2 agreed (82 didn't mention this).
Itay17, Lepricavark
  • Around on IRC to help out with issues. They've been helpful to me in many situations, most not related to steward stuff, but still there nonetheless. Net positive.
1 agreed (83 didn't mention this).
BU Rob13
  • Encouraging a volunteer to work more cannot be done by kicking him. Also, every good action done for the community is a good action that helps others to do more good actions.
1 agreed (83 didn't mention this).
.js
  • Great editor
1 agreed (83 didn't mention this).
Fastily
Concerned
  • low activity / not active enough, little use has been criticized for years, announcement of reduced activity not promising for the future
8 agreed, 12 seconded (64 didn't mention this).
Vogone[Steinsplitter, Stemoc, Gce, Cameron11598, DCB, MechQuester, 小躍, KPFC, Jianhui67], Atcovi, Iazyges, Uğurkent, MF-Warburg[Natuur12, Rxy, Nemo bis], Fastily, AlvaroMolina, NickK
  • No need / no point of having the tools with his level of usage / no demonstrated need for the right
5 agreed, 3 seconded (76 didn't mention this).
Cameron11598, Laurent Jerry, JustBerry, Widr, MF-Warburg[Natuur12, Rxy, Nemo bis]
  • Little or no activity behind the scenes
3 agreed, 5 seconded (76 didn't mention this).
MF-Warburg[Natuur12, Rxy, Nemo bis], Ajraddatz[Natuur12, Shanmugamp7], Snowolf
  • Not active on Wikiversity since 2008
1 agreed (83 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter
  • no reason given
7 agreed (77 didn't mention this).
O.Koslowski, Gridditsch, Richardkiwi, Plagiat, KlaasZ4usV, Alan, Ofek j

  • 2 neutral "comments" (i.e. without comment).

Bennylin edit

55 users commented on Bennylin's confirmation. Final revision r16366973.

Favourable
  • no reason given
15 agreed (40 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu, Jianhui67, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Miniapolis, Bookvaedina, Jusjih, Leon saudanha, CreativeC38, Wagino 20100516, Samuele2002, Jerrykim306, Barras, Minoo, Zyephyrus
  • good to go
1 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Liuxinyu970226
  • valuable language expertise
1 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Snowolf
  • the majority of the actions/comments mentioned in the first !vote don't feel abusive/dangerous to me
1 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Nemo bis
Concerned
  • (Repeated) erroneous actions caused by long periods of inactivity (out of touch with current practices)
3 agreed, 10 seconded (42 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754[Rax, Iazyges, Ah3kal, NickK, MarcoAurelio, Lepricavark, BU Rob13, Kurtis, Matanya[Quiddity]], Thogo, JustBerry
  • Inactivity
3 agreed (52 didn't mention this).
Natuur12, AlvaroMolina, Fastily
  • "Similar words from other confirmations, though unrealised following confirmation"
1 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Billinghurst
  • Repeated mistakes and no attempt to address the concerns or to avoid repeating them
1 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Snowolf
  • "Glad to say goodbye with you"
1 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Meracritus
  • no reason given
14 agreed (41 didn't mention this).
Stemoc, Atcovi, Marshallsumter, Krd, Marcus Cyron, Ajraddatz, Pnapora, Gridditsch, Plagiat, cyfraw, MGChecker, KlaasZ4usV, Xqt, Alan

  • 3 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment); 1 "not able to really make [his] mind"; 1 "per negative opinions".

Bsadowski1 edit

71 users commented on Bsadowski1's confirmation. Final revision r16366981.

Favourable
  • no reason given
47 agreed (24 didn't mention this).
Jianhui67, Vituzzu, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Juliancolton, Fastily, Miniapolis, StevenJ81, Bookvaedina, DCB, Jusjih, MoiraMoira, Shivanarayana, Leon saudanha, Krd, Matanya, Gordonrox24, Thogo, Avraham, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Druddigon, Samuele2002, Archenzo, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, JustBerry, Widr, Natuur12, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, TJH2018, cyfraw, İncelemeelemani, Barras, Eraevsky, Zyephyrus, Kurtis, Geoide, Rxy, Quiddity, Uğurkent, Masti, Mifter, Pmlineditor, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, KlaasZ4usV, Teles, Alan, Etamni
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
21 agreed (50 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Vogone, Liuxinyu970226, Alvaro Molina, Cameron11598, Ajraddatz, Atcovi, Ah3kal, TBloemink, NickK, MarcoAurelio, Ping08, Billinghurst, Palnatoke, Hanay, Kelvin, RadiX, Snowolf, NahidSultan, Savh, -revi
Concerned
  • not very active cross-wiki
1 agreed (70 didn't mention this).
Laurent Jerry
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (70 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter

  • 1 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment).

DerHexer edit

203 users commented on DerHexer's confirmation. Final revision r16367626.

Favourable
  • no reason given
158 agreed (45 didn't mention this).
Shivanarayana, Jianhui67, Vituzzu, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Yarl, Ganímedes, Murma174, Altkatholik62, Miniapolis, Ra'ike, Marcus Cyron, Rlbberlin, Fastily, StevenJ81, Gereon K., Bookvaedina, Rax, MechQuester, Wuselig, Jusjih, PawełMM, Freddy2001, MoiraMoira, Udo T., Nolispanmo, Linedwell, Leon saudanha, Redlinux, Bubo bubo, Didi43, Chansey, Maximilian Schönherr, Do not follow, Gunslinger.1970, Emptywords, Krd, Samuele2002, MannMaus, Matanya, Coffins, Cirdan, Thogo, Avraham, Brainswiffer, Andreas Werle, Howan Hansi, Jbergner, MEW, Exoport, Eschenmoser, Wagino 20100516, Gripweed, Squasher, Enzian44, 1971markus, Samuele2002, Pankoken, Stefan64, Archenzo, WolfgangRieger, Jivee Blau, S.Didam, Holder, Clemensfranz, Ghilt, Informationswiedergutmachung, Geolina163, Baumfreund-FFM, Millbart, Gridditsch, Kpisimon, Commander-pirx, Stryn, Julle, Codc, YaganZ, Lutheraner, Partynia, XaviYuahanda, Arash.pt, Pittimann, PaulaMeh, Agricolax, Plagiat, SDKmac, JustBerry, Helfmann, Andim, Slökmann, Trollflöjten, JWBE, Natuur12, Mellebga, AFBorchert, Baladid, Elisauer, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, Kein Einstein, Hardenacke, Widr, Aquilinae, Gulaschkanone99, Wibramuc, Trigonomie, TJH2018, Brackenheim, Darwinius, cyfraw, FNDE, Steschke, S. F. B. Morse, İncelemeelemani, MB-one, WhoisWhoME, Matthias Süßen, Unscheinbar, Berihert, FriedhelmW, Barras, Raboe001, Lena1, MarcelBuehner, Steindy, Zyephyrus, -jkb-, Alan ffm, Septembermorgen, MBurch, Euku, Kritzolina, Kurtis, Nixnubix, Rxy, Taivo, Quiddity, Gerhardvalentin, Uğurkent, Otberg, Masti, Schwarz7201, Iazyges, DoRD, Geagea, Rzuwig, TBloemink, Ping08, Woudloper, MarcoAurelio, MisterSynergy, Viciarg, Botulph, Jmvkrecords, Teles, Alan, Martin Kraft
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
43 agreed (160 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Vogone, KPFC, Steinsplitter, Liuxinyu970226, Pearli, Alvaro Molina, Ah3kal, Ajraddatz, Bjarlin, EddieGP, OrbiliusMagister, Atcovi, 小躍, NickK, Susann Schweden, KlaasZ4usV, Tony1, Laurent Jerry, Billinghurst, Hasive, Sänger, Palnatoke, Code, Meno25, Neozoon, Jonathan Groß, Man77, RudolfSimon, Sj, KoriAna 1, Itti, Ralf Roletschek, RadiX, Ptolusque, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, NahidSultan, Savh, .js, Alex Pereira, -revi, Xqt
Concerned
  • no reason given
1 agreed (202 didn't mention this).
Giftpflanze
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (202 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter

Einsbor edit

76 users commented on Einsbor's confirmation. Final revision r16366987.

Favourable
  • no reason given
57 agreed (19 didn't mention this).
Jianhui67, Vituzzu, Steinsplitter, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Michał Sobkowski, Yarl, Torrosbak, Fastily, StevenJ81, Bookvaedina, DCB, MechQuester, Jusjih, PawełMM, MoiraMoira, Shivanarayana, Leon saudanha, CreativeC38, Ptjackyll, Chansey, Do not follow, Emptywords, Elfhelm, Krd, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Pnapora, Gridditsch, Stryn, Plagiat, Altkatholik62, Natuur12, Elmie, Melos, Darwinius, cyfraw, Barras,Eraevsky, Zyephyrus, Alan ffm, Rxy, Quiddity, Uğurkent, Masti, Alvaro Molina, Cybularny, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, MarcoAurelio
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
18 agreed (185 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Vogone, 4nn1l2, Liuxinyu970226, Ajraddatz, Atcovi, Ah3kal, NickK, KlaasZ4usV, Neonek12, Laurent Jerry, Billinghurst, Lepricavark, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, Savh, NahidSultan
Concerned
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (75 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter

Hoo man edit

105 users commented on Hoo man's confirmation. Final revision r16367638.

Favourable
  • no reason given
84 agreed (21 didn't mention this).
Steinsplitter, Jianhui67, Vituzzu, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Martin Urbanec, Ra'ike, Fastily, StevenJ81, Gereon K., Mbch331, Bookvaedina, DCB, -jkb-, Rax, Jusjih, MoiraMoira, Udo T., Nolispanmo, Leon saudanha, Didi43, CreativeC38, Krd, Matanya, Coffins, Cirdan, Thogo, Avraham, Andreas Werle, Jbergner, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Enzian44, 1971markus, Sänger, Holder, Geolina163, Jivee Blau, Gridditsch, Stryn, Commander-pirx, Julle, Codc, Plagiat, Altkatholik62, JustBerry, Helfmann, Natuur12, Elmie, Melos, Calak, Meno25, Matej Suchánek, JackPotte, Brackenheim, Darwinius, cyfraw, SDKmac, S. F. B. Morse, Matthias Süßen, Barras, Raboe001, Eraevsky, Zyephyrus, S.Didam, Kritzolina, Rxy, Quiddity, Biplab Anand, Ugurkent, masti, Schwarz7201, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, Ping08, KlaasZ4usV, MarcoAurelio, MisterSynergy, Teles, Martin Kraft, Xqt
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
19 agreed (86 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Vogone, Liuxinyu970226, Bjarlin, Atcovi, Ah3kal, NickK, Syum90, Billinghurst, Ghilt, Lepricavark, Itti, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, Savh, NahidSultan, .js, -revi
Concerned
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (104 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter
  • no reason given
1 agreed (104 didn't mention this).
Informationswiedergutmachung

Jyothis edit

62 users commented on Jyothis's confirmation. Final revision r16366999.

Favourable
  • no reason given
44 agreed (18 didn't mention this).
Jianhui67, Vituzzu, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Fastily, Bookvaedina, DCB, Jusjih, MoiraMoira, Shivanarayana, Leon saudanha, Krd, Samuele2002, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, JustBerry, AryanSogd, Natuur12, Elmie, Melos, Meno25, cyfraw, Barras, Eraevsky, Zyephyrus, Rxy, Quiddity, Biplab Anand, Masti, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, MarcoAurelio, Teles
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
15 agreed (47 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Vogone, Liuxinyu970226, Ah3kal, Ajraddatz, Atcovi, NickK, KlaasZ4usV, Billinghurst, Lepricavark, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, Savh, NahidSultan
Concerned
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (61 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter
  • not active enough
1 agreed (61 didn't mention this).
Uğurkent

1 neutral "comment" (i.e. without a comment).

Linedwell edit

65 users commented on Linedwell's confirmation. Final revision r16367001.

Favourable
  • no reason given
48 agreed (17 didn't mention this).
Jianhui67, Vituzzu, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Fastily, Bookvaedina, DCB, Thibaut120094, Jusjih, MoiraMoira, Leon saudanha, Kumkum, Do not follow, Krd, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, Plagiat, Mattho69, Natuur12, Elmie, Melos, cyfraw, Geoide, Barras, Eraevsky, Minoo, Zyephyrus, Rxy, Quiddity, Ugurkent, masti, Ajraddatz, Umberto NURS, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, MarcoAurelio, Housterdam, RadiX
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
16 agreed (49 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Vogone, Steinsplitter, Liuxinyu970226, FrankyLeRoutier, Ah3kal, Atcovi, NickK, KlaasZ4usV, Billinghurst, Lepricavark, Kikuyu3, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, Savh, NahidSultan
Concerned
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter

MBisanz edit

70 users commented on MBisanz's confirmation. Final revision r16367005.

Favourable
  • no reason given
53 agreed (17 didn't mention this).
Jianhui67, Vituzzu, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Fastily, Miniapolis, Bookvaedina, DCB, Marshallsumter, Jusjih, MoiraMoira, Leon saudanha, Chansey, Holmium, Ankry, Krd, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, YaganZ, Plagiat, Natuur12, AFBorchert, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, Meno25, cyfraw, Barras, Eraevsky, Zyephyrus, Ultraexactzz, Quiddity, Ugurkent, Masti, Mifter, Taivo, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, MarcoAurelio, Teles, Alan, Sj
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
16 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Vogone, Liuxinyu970226, Ajraddatz, Atcovi, Ah3kal, NickK, AFBorchert, KlaasZ4usV, Tony1, Billinghurst, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, Savh, NahidSultan
Concerned
  • does not need steward rights anymore
1 agreed (69 didn't mention this).
Stemoc

MF-Warburg edit

108 users commented on MF-Warburg's confirmation. Final revision r16380700.

Favourable
  • no reason given
79 agreed (29 didn't mention this).
Shivanarayana, Vituzzu, GZWDer, Murma174, Fastily, StevenJ81, Bookvaedina, DCB, Rax, Marshallsumter, Jusjih, Freddy2001, MoiraMoira, Udo T., Nolispanmo, Leon saudanha, Redlinux, CreativeC38, Bubo bubo, Nungalpiriggal, Chansey, Do not follow, Ankry, Krd, Samuele2002, Matanya, Coffins, SMAUG, Thogo, Avraham, Brainswiffer, Andreas Werle, Jbergner, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Enzian44, 1971markus, Archenzo, Sänger, Ghilt, Geolina163, Gridditsch, Stryn, Codc, Arash.pt, SDKmac, JustBerry, AryanSogd, Natuur12, Elmie, Melos, Meno25, Hardenacke, TJH2018, Brackenheim, Darwinius, cyfraw, S. F. B. Morse, Incelemeelemani, S.Didam, Barras, Raboe001, Minoo, Zyephyrus, Alan ffm, Rxy, Quiddity, Masti, Pmlineditor, Xqt, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, KlaasZ4usV, MarcoAurelio, Elvaube, Sj
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
23 agreed (85 didn't mention this).
Vogone, Steinsplitter, Rschen7754, 4nn1l2, KPFC, Liuxinyu970226, Ah3kal, Ajraddatz, Bjarlin, NickK, Billinghurst, Palnatoke, Commander-pirx, Lepricavark, Itti, Kelvin, Taivo, Biplad Anand, Uğurkent, Snowolf, Savh, NahidSultan, -revi
Concerned
  • no thanks
1 agreed (107 didn't mention this).
Eurodyne
  • no reason given
1 agreed (107 didn't mention this).
Informationswiedergutmachung

4 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment).

MarcoAurelio edit

98 users commented on MarcoAurelio's confirmation. Final revision r16380749.

Favourable
  • no reason given
67 agreed (31 didn't mention this).
Shivanarayana, Vituzzu, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Ganímedes, Murma174, Euphydryas, Bjarlin, Fastily, StevenJ81, Bookvaedina, Rax, MechQuester, Marshallsumter, Jusjih, MoiraMoira, Udo T., Leon saudanha, Samuele2002, Nungalpiriggal, Do not follow, Taichi, Krd, Matanya, Thogo, La Mantis, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Lucas, Gridditsch, Stryn, JustBerry, AryanSogd, Natuur12, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, Lautaro 97, Matej Suchánek, Widr, TJH2018, Darwinius, Cyfraw, SDKmac, Barras, Zyephyrus, Taivo, Geoide, L736E, Rxy, Quiddity, Ugurkent, Masti, Xqt, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Xaosflux, Rzuwig, TBloemink, Ping08, Alan, Melquíades
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
30 agreed, 1 seconded (67 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Steinsplitter, Jianhui67, Liuxinyu970226, Herbythyme, Yeza, Martin Urbanec, -revi, Ah3kal, Ajraddatz, Atcovi, Savh, Ruthven, This\, that and the other, NickK, Hayordi, Syum90, CreativeC38, Tursetic, KlaasZ4usV, Billinghurst[Pmlineditor], YaganZ, Plagiat, Jmvkrecords, Odder, Itti, Biplad Anand, RadiX, Snowolf, NahidSultan

Mardetanha edit

66 users commented on Mardetanha's confirmation. Final revision r16367017.

Favourable
  • no reason given
45 agreed (21 didn't mention this).
GZWDer, Jianhui67, Arian, Fastily, Bookvaedina, -jkb-, Rax, MechQuester, Jusjih, Leon saudanha, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Visem, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Gridditsch, Stryn, Sunfyre, Arash.pt, Julle, Natuur12, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, Calak, Darwinius, cyfraw, Behzad39, Barras, Taivo, Zyephyrus, Rxy, Quiddity, Biplab Anand, Masti, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, Woudloper, آرش, MarcoAurelio, Alex Pereira,
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
12 agreed (54 didn't mention this).
Ks-M9, Liuxinyu970226, AlvaroMolina, MoiraMoira, NickK, Billinghurst, Meno25, AFlorence, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, NahidSultan
  • issues mentioned are not too bad / he realized it was not OK / AGF
6 agreed (60 didn't mention this).
Atcovi, KlaasZ4usV, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, NahidSultan, Savh
  • doing his best in off-wiki activities
1 agreed (65 didn't mention this).
MohammadtheEditor,
Concerned
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (65 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter
  • not (that) active
2 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754, Steinsplitter
  • one action far from the temperament I would expect from a steward
2 agreed, 1 seconded (63 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754[Miniapolis], Snowolf

4 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment).

Masti edit

81 users commented on Masti's confirmation. Final revision r16367018.

Favourable
  • no reason given
61 agreed (20 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu, Jianhui67, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Michal Sobkowski, Yarl, Torrosbak, Martin Urbanec, Fastily, Bookvaedina, DCB, Rax, MechQuester, Marshallsumter, Jusjih, PawelMM, MoiraMoira, Leon saudanha, Ptjackyll, Do not follow, Emptywords, Elfhelm, Ankry, Krd, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Visem, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Hasive, Archenzo, Ghilt, Pnapora, Gridditsch, Stryn, Arbnos, JustBerry, Рулин, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, TJH2018, Darwinius, Barras, Eraevsky, Minoo, Zyephyrus, Alan ffm, Rxy, Quiddity, Nemo_bis, Uğurkent, Xqt, AlvaroMolina, Cybularny, DoRD, Iazyges, TBloemink, Ping08, KlaasZ4usV,
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
18 agreed (63 didn't mention this).
Rzuwig, Liuxinyu970226, Kayer Ahmad, Ah3kal, Ajraddatz, Atcovi, NickK, Syum90, Neonek12, Billinghurst, Plagiat, Natuur12, Itti, Kelvin, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, NahidSultan
  • only one bad mistake, not in itself grounds for removal
1 agreed (80 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754

1 neutral "comment" (i.e. without a comment).

Matanya edit

94 users commented on Matanya's confirmation. Final revision r16380750.

Favourable
  • no reason given
66 agreed (28 didn't mention this).
Jianhui67, Vituzzu, Shivanarayana, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Martin Urbanec, Fastily, Bookvaedina, DCB, -jkb-, MechQuester, MoiraMoira, Thogo, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, Daryag, JustBerry, Ovedc, Nittai Gallili,מנחם.אל, קובץ על יד, Eladti, AryanSogd, שמזן, IKhitron, AFBorchert, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, Borochov edit, Assayas, Darwinius, Cyfraw, BRINKS, Barras, Taivo, Eraevsky, Minoo, Zyephyrus, Itzike, Hanay, Geoide, 1Or, Rxy, Quiddity, Uğurkent, Masti, Mifter, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, MarcoAurelio, Ping08, KlaasZ4usV, לסטר, MisterSynergy, Alleycat80, Ofek j
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
23 agreed (71 didn't mention this).
Steinsplitter, Rschen7754, Liuxinyu970226, Cameron11598, Ah3kal, Nahum, Atcovi, Geagea, NickK, Leon saudanha, Billinghust, -revi, MathKnight, בורה בורה, אמא של גולן, Natuur12, Liadmalone, Ravit, Deror avi, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, NahidSultan
Concerned
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (93 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter
  • copyright violations on Commons
1 agreed (93 didn't mention this).
Kkairri
  • would appreciate more activity
1 agreed (93 didn't mention this).
Savh

2 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment).

Melos edit

75 users commented on Melos' confirmation. Final revision r16367695.

Favourable
  • no reason given
22 agreed (53 didn't mention this).
Ks-M9, GZWDer, Pracchia-78, Bookvaedina, Bjarlin, Jusjih, Samuele2002, Aplasia, Archenzo, Civvì, Ruthven, Elwood, Lepido, Demart81, cyfraw, Geoide, Barras, Zyephyrus, masti, Mifter, Shivanarayana, An Macanese,
  • good to go
1 agreed (74 didn't mention this).
Liuxinyu970226
  • more than 0 actions
5 agreed, 12 seconded (58 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu[Syum90, Phyrexian, Matanya, Avraham[Quiddity], .snoopy., Rodrigodacuna, Ask21, RadiX], Thogo[Avraham], Dome, L736E, .js
  • for honestly stating that he was not as active as he wanted to be
1 agreed (74 didn't mention this).
NickK,
  • inactivity can be overlooked one time
1 agreed (74 didn't mention this).
Billinghurst
  • polite and helpful
1 agreed (74 didn't mention this).
Pegasovagante
Concerned
  • inactivity
22 agreed, 1 seconded (52 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754[DCB], Vogone, Jianhui67, Steinsplitter, Stemoc, AlvaroMolina, Ah3kal, Fastily, Ajraddatz, Iazyges, Savh, TBloemink, Leon saudanha, Alan, Ofek j, Uğurkent, Miniapolis, Umberto NURS, Hypergio, MarcoAurelio, Natuur12, Elmie
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (74 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter
  • no reason given
6 agreed (69 didn't mention this).
Atcovi, Krd, Marcus Cyron, Gridditsch, Plagiat, KlaasZ4usV

4 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment), 1 "removed vote"

  • On the one hand, I don't really agree with inactivity-only removals. But I see no consensus to confirm here, and as such I say remove. Unless it is being very unreasonable or incorrect in its reasoning, the community should have the final say here. – Ajraddatz (talk) 09:26, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
  • According to SP removal implies loss of trust. A significant minority, from a numerical point of view, pointed out inactivity-related concerns, but none of them questioned Melos' trustworthiness. Same for Avraham: no consensus to remove, then keep. --Vituzzu (talk) 09:53, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
    From SP: "lose it if they do not need it or are no longer trusted". So, not necessary loss of trust. Ruslik (talk) 20:33, 6 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
  • Vituzzu is correct that none have questioned Melos' trustworthiness, on the other hand several community members are concerned about Melos not being active enough. I'm going for a keep here due to the fact that I feel that trust is more important than editcounts, but Melos should certainly become more active as the community values activity too. —MarcoAurelio 10:47, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
  • weak confirm —DerHexer (Talk) 15:28, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
  • Remove - Multiple concerns were expressed about the lack of steward actions, including however a previous concern by myself. The currently ongoing explosive increase in activity from Melos does not seem to guarantee a continued higher activity level, though. Savhñ 15:29, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
    Still none of them points out lack of trust which is what SP deals with. --Vituzzu (talk) 19:54, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
    When electing stewards, the community trust them, among other things, to be active. Melos currently is only active now, and the community has shown, as far as I see, a significant concern with their trust in Melos' activity. Savhñ 09:11, 7 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
    Since 2010 I've guaranteed a sufficient level of activity as steward in serving community (as we can see in many comments). Some months of the last year there was lack of activity due to absence of connettivity (there was significant changes in my RL that I can't explain here for privacy reason but if someone will ask to me I'm happy to clarify privately) and some concerns are indeed about that but only if this lack is reiterated. Now since all my connettivity problems are resolved I can guaranted a good level of activity (see CW activity) as expected by many commmunity comments and that trust my steward actions. --Melos (talk) 13:31, 7 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
  • Remove. Low activity is a concern which is shared by so many users that makes me unable to say confirm, sadly. Matiia (talk) 16:13, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
  • Confirm. Low activity does not indicate a poor understanding of the role and its tools. I have not lost faith in Melos's abilities and his contributions are valuable. We (myself obviously as well) may want to reconsider the current minimum activity levels for stewards as there is a significant portion of the community which desires more, but until such point as either Melos demonstrates improper use of the tools, repeated poor judgement, or falls below the mandated minimum, I see no reason not to benefit from his experience. -- Avi (talk) 20:53, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
  • remove The concerns about low activity are shared by many users. It was also rightly pointed out that inactivity is bad as it leads to being uninformed about current practices and new policies. --MF-W 21:44, 5 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
Ignoring SP is bad, ignoring it basing upon theoretical considerations is even worse. --Vituzzu (talk) 18:51, 6 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
Which part of it did I ignore? --MF-W 15:19, 7 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
Removal-related part, as I wrote above. --Vituzzu (talk) 17:35, 7 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
This is probably not the place for this (and it hurts me in particular) but I think you both have legs to stand on as I believe there is an ambiguity in the SP. One the one hand, we have a clear definition of what minimum activity is at Stewards policy#Inactivity. On the other hand, there is the following statement in the next section Stewards policy#Poll after a year: "Users get it if they need it, keep it if people trust them, and lose it if they do not need it or are no longer trusted." Vituzzu, I, and others understand that "do not need it" means that they have not kept to the minimum requirement, which means anyone who has kept to the minimum can only be removed if his or her peers show a consensus to remove (as per the rest of the paragraph) based on a loss of trust in the ability for the user to function properly. MFW, If I understand him correctly, feels that "no longer needed" can be a standard higher than that listed in the previous section. I've always argued that if that is the case, we should adjust the minimum, as a clearly stated requirement trumps an ambiguous one, in my opinion. However, if MFW loses trust in someone (me, Benny, Melos) solely due to their lack of activity, that is his prerogative. -- Avi (talk) 17:46, 7 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]
To me, the sentence "Users get it if etc." is more a "decoration" or a comment than a policy. It isn't enforcable, and also not strictly true: it's not like any user who "needs" steward access (however such a need would be defined) gets it first, and that only afterwards it's determined whether he may keep it based on people's trust. Much more important are the sentences which follow, which describe the actual removal process. That process is completely independent from the automatic inactivity removal. --MF-W 16:19, 8 March 2017 (UTC)Reply[reply]

Mentifisto edit

57 users commented on Mentifisto's confirmation. Final revision r16367028.

Favourable
  • no reason given
35 agreed (22 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu, Jianhui67, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Fastily, Bookvaedina, DCB, MechQuester, OrbiliusMagister, Jusjih, MoiraMoira, Leon saudanha, Ankry, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, cyfraw, Barras, Eraevsky, Minoo, Zyephyrus, masti, Mifter, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink
  • "good"
2 agreed (55 didn't mention this).
Vogone, Liuxinyu970226
  • Activity level is alright
2 agreed (55 didn't mention this).
Atcovi, NickK
  • We all make mistakes
1 agreed (56 didn't mention this).
Miniapolis
  • legit concerns, not enough to justify opposing SC given his other skills
1 agreed (56 didn't mention this).
RadiX
  • Admitted his mistake re CU
1 agreed (56 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754
Concerned
  • Lack of activity
5 agreed, 3 seconded (49 didn't mention this).
Savh[Ah3kal, Natuur12], Rschen7754, MarcoAurelio, Ajraddatz[Snowolf], Uğurkent
  • Granting of advanced rights on a home wiki
3 agreed, 2 seconded (52 didn't mention this).
Savh[Ah3kal, Natuur12], Rschen7754, Billinghurst
  • Granting of CheckUser rights on a wiki without a second checkuser
4 agreed, 3 seconded (50 didn't mention this).
Savh[Ah3kal, Natuur12], Gce, NickK, Ajraddatz[Snowolf]
  • out of touch with current practices
3 agreed, 1 seconded (53 didn't mention this).
Savh, Ajraddatz[Snowolf], Quiddity
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (56 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter
  • no reason given
2 agreed (55 didn't mention this).
Gridditsch, Plagiat

2 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment).

NahidSultan edit

78 users commented on NahidSultan's confirmation. Final revision r16367029.

Favourable
  • no reason given
59 agreed (19 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu, GZWDer, Chansey, Mahir256, Marcus Cyron, Fastily, StevenJ81, Gereon K., Bookvaedina, DCB, MechQuester, Marshallsumter, Arif80s, PawełMM, MoiraMoira, Shivanarayana, Udo T., Leon saudanha, Ankry, Krd, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, Aftabuzzaman, Plagiat, JustBerry, AryanSogd, Natuur12, آرش, Nabin K. Sapkota, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, Meno25, cyfraw, İncelemeelemani, Taivo, Barras, Zyephyrus, Kritzolina, Nan, Rxy, Quiddity, Biplab Anand, Uğurkent, Masti, Atcovi, Ajraddatz, DoRD, Iazyges, Geagea, Rzuwig, MarcoAurelio, KlaasZ4usV
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
18 agreed (60 didn't mention this).
Vogone, Rschen7754, Ks-M9, Liuxinyu970226, Kayser Ahmad, AlvaroMolina, Ah3kal, TBloemink, NickK, Syum90, Hasive, Billinghurst, Harvinder Chandigarh, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, Jianhui67, -revi

1 neutral "comment" (i.e. without a comment).

Pmlineditor edit

60 users commented on Pmlineditor's confirmation. Final revision r16381322.

Favourable
  • no reason given
25 agreed (35 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu, GZWDer, Mahir256, Bookvaedina, MechQuester, Jusjih, MoiraMoira, Leon saudanha, Matanya, Gordonrox24, Thogo, Avraham, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Stryn, Natuur12, Lepricavark, Melos, Cyfraw, Barras, Minoo, Zyephyrus, Mifter, TBloemink, An Macanese
  • good steward / good work / active / (still) trusted etc.
7 agreed, 1 seconded (52 didn't mention this).
Ks-M9, Liuxinyu970226, Juliancolton[Jianhui67], Syum90, Billinghurst, RadiX, Snowolf
  • long-term dedication & promised to not seek confirmation next year if he keeps being inactive / giving him another chance / hope he will increase his activity this year / encouraging a volunteer to work more cannot be done by kicking him
5 agreed, 1 seconded (54 didn't mention this).
Juliancolton[Jianhui67], Ah3kal, NickK, .js, Miniapolis
Concerned
  • inactivity
12 agreed, 4 seconded (44 didn't mention this).
Ah3kal, Vogone[DCB], Stemoc, Steinsplitter, Iazyges, Uğurkent, Rschen7754[MarcoAurelio[Luke081515]], AlvaroMolina, Fastily, StevenJ81, Ajraddatz[Quiddity], Elmie
  • no reason given
7 agreed (53 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter, Krd, Gridditsch, Plagiat, Chris troutman, Atcovi, KlaasZ4uV

1 neutral "comment" (i.e. without a comment).

QuiteUnusual edit

63 users commented on QuiteUnusual's confirmation. Final revision r16367031.

Favourable
  • no reason given
48 agreed (15 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu, Jianhui67, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Fastily, Bookvaedina, DCB, MechQuester, Atcovi, MoiraMoira, Shivanarayana, Leon saudanha, CreativeC38, Krd, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, Plagiat, Widr, Natuur12, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, JackPotte, cyfraw, Barras, Eraevsky, Minoo, Zyephyrus, Geoide, Quiddity, Uğurkent, Masti, Mifter, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, MarcoAurelio, KlaasZ4usV, Sj
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
14 agreed (49 didn't mention this).
Vogone, Rschen7754, Liuxinyu970226, AlvaroMolina, Ah3kal, Ajraddatz, Miniapolis, Savh, NickK, Syum90, Billinghurst, RadiX, Pmlineditor, Snowolf
Concerned
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (62 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter

RadiX edit

79 users commented on RadiX's confirmation. Final revision r16367033.

Favourable
  • no reason given
63 agreed (16 didn't mention this).
Vituzzu, Jianhui67, Shivanarayana, Ks-M9, GZWDer, Martin Urbanec, Fastily, StevenJ81, Bookvaedina, DCB, MechQuester, Atcovi, Castelobranco, Marshallsumter, Jusjih, PawełMM, MoiraMoira, Udo T., Leon saudanha, CreativeC38, Nungalpiriggal, Do not follow, Taichi, Ixocactus, Krd, Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Marcus Cyron, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Stryn, Julle, Plagiat, JustBerry, AryanSogd, Natuur12, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, Darwinius, Cyfraw, Etamni, Barras, Zyephyrus, Geoide, Rxy, Quiddity, Biplab Anand, Masti, Yeza, Marcelo Victor, AlvaroMolina, DoRD, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, MarcoAurelio, KlaasZ4usV, Ping08, Jmvkrecords
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
15 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Vogone, Rschen7754, EVinente, Liuxinyu970226, Ah3kal, Ajraddatz, Savh, NickK, Syum90, Billinghurst, Érico, Uğurkent, Pmlineditor, Snowolf, Alex Pereira

1 neutral "comment" (i.e. without a comment)

Ruslik0 edit

65 users commented on Ruslik0's confirmation. Final revision r16367034.

Favourable
  • no reason given
40 agreed (25 didn't mention this).
GZWDer, Martin Urbanec, Steinsplitter, Fastily, Miniapolis, Bookvaedina, -jkb-, MechQuester, PawełMM, MoiraMoira, Ankax Hayastan, Udo T., Matanya, Thogo, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Wagino 20100516, Ghilt, Gridditsch, Arbnos, Plagiat, Рулин, Elmie, Melos, Cyfraw, Barras, Eraevsky, Zyephyrus, Masti, AlvaroMolina, Iazyges, Rzuwig, TBloemink, Leon saudanha, Tursetic, MarcoAurelio, Ping08, KlaasZ4uV, לסטר, Billinghurst
  • good steward / good work / active / trusted etc.
4 agreed (61 didn't mention this).
Ks-M9, Liuxinyu970226, Itti, Ah3kal
  • has done more good than bad actions / overall net positive
3 agreed (62 didn't mention this).
Atcovi, Syum90, Pmlineditor
  • has always been a steward who got things done
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Vogone
  • only Russian-speaking steward
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Brateevsky
  • not enough reason to remove
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Jianhui67
  • per confidence from other stewards and globalsysops
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Quiddity
  • confident that he will learn from his mistakes
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
RadiX
Concerned
  • problematic behaviour / mistakes
2 agreed, 6 seconded (57 didn't mention this).
Rschen7754[Anatoliy, KPFC, Uğurkent, Snowolf, Vogone, Ah3kal], NickK[Anatoliy, KPFC, Uğurkent]
  • please be more careful
2 agreed (63 didn't mention this).
Atcovi, Savh
  • unwillingness to listen to valuable criticism
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Snowolf
  • I sometimes disagree with certain actions by Ruslik, but usually due to excessive "caution"
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Nemo bis
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter
  • no reason given
1 agreed (64 didn't mention this).
Lepricavark

2 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment).

Savh edit

82 users commented on Savh's confirmation. Final revision r16367035.

Favourable
  • no reason given / positive comments
82 agreed (0 didn't mention this).

Shanmugamp7 edit

61 users commented on Shanmugamp7's confirmation. Final revision r16367038.

Favourable
  • no reason given / positive comments
61 agreed (0 didn't mention this).

Stryn edit

75 users commented on Stryn's confirmation. Final revision r16367040.

Favourable
  • no reason given / positive comments
75 agreed (0 didn't mention this).

Tegel edit

73 users commented on Tegel's confirmation. Final revision r16367328.

Favourable
  • no reason given / positive comments
73 agreed (0 didn't mention this).

Teles edit

72 users commented on Teles's confirmation. Final revision r16367044.

Favourable
  • no reason given / positive comments
70 agreed (2 didn't mention this).
Concerned
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (71 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter

1 neutral "comment" (i.e. without a comment).

Trijnstel edit

91 users commented on Trijnstel's confirmation. Final revision r16371468.

Favourable
  • no reason given / positive comments
84 agreed (7 didn't mention this).
Concerned
  • not enough activity
2 agreed (89 didn't mention this).
Steinsplitter, Uğurkent
  • "task reduction recommended"
1 agreed (90 didn't mention this).
Plagiat
  • "too many notes in her singing"
1 agreed (90 didn't mention this).
Richardkiwi
  • too many "hats in too much projects"
1 agreed (90 didn't mention this).
Marcus Cyron
  • not active on Wikiversity
1 agreed (90 didn't mention this).
Marshallsumter

1 neutral "comment" (i.e. without a comment).

Vituzzu edit

102 users commented on Vituzzu's confirmation. Final revision r16367050.

Favourable
  • no reason given
76 agreed (26 didn't mention this).
Jianhui67, GZWDer, Rodrigodacuna, Yeza, Euphydryas, AlvaroMolina, Lenka64, Martin Urbanec, Nungalpiriggal, Chansey, -jkb-, Pracchia-78, Fastily, Bookvaedina, DCB, Lepido, Mr-Shadow, MechQuester, OrbiliusMagister, DoRD, -revi, Yiyi, Iazyges, Geagea, Aplasia, MoiraMoira, Rzuwig, Umberto NURS, TBloemink, Udo T., Leon saudanha, Woudloper, Hypergio, MarcoAurelio, Ping08, Krd, Eumolpo, KlaasZ4uV, Thogo, Avraham, Howan Hansi, Wagino 20100516, Archenzo, Ghilt, Dome, Lucas, Gridditsch, Stryn, Tchoř, Kal-El, JustBerry, AryanSogd, Fernando.tassone, Jmvkrecords, KoriAna 1, Elmie, Lepricavark, Melos, Matěj Suchánek, TJH2018, Cyfraw, İncelemeelemani, Barras, Eraevsky, Samuele2002, Zyephyrus, Harlock81, Шухрат Саъдиев, Alex brollo, L736E, Melquíades, Rxy, Quiddity, Biplab Anand, Uğurkent, Masti
  • good steward / good work / active etc.
24 agreed (78 didn't mention this).
Steinsplitter, Rschen7754, Shivanarayana, Ks-M9, Liuxinyu970226, Ah3kal, Natuur12, Cameron11598, Ajraddatz, Rax, Savh, Marshallsumter, Ruthven, NickK, Syum90, Do not follow, Taivo, Billinghurst, -revi, Geoide, Sintakso, Itti, RadiX, Snowolf
Concerned
  • thinks he is above the rules
1 agreed (101 didn't mention this).
Auvajs
  • blocks of innocent contributors, biased against some users
1 agreed (101 didn't mention this).
Juandev

2 neutral "comments" (i.e. without a comment).

Return to "Stewards/Confirm/2017" page.