@metadata | sourceLanguage | "en" |
---|
priorityLanguages | |
---|
allowOnlyPriorityLanguages | true |
---|
description | "video in Introduction to Partnership Building (computer-graded exercises) - Basics of partnership building for Wikimedia volunteers, with computer-graded exercises." |
---|
label | "WikiLearn - Introduction to Partnership Building (computer-graded exercises) - video: Examples for assignment 6" |
---|
|
---|
display_name | "Examples for assignment 6" |
---|
subtitle-840-3770-1 | "Feedback on assignment number six." |
---|
subtitle-3780-8850-2 | "The assignment about Partnership Value Proposal the PVP." |
---|
subtitle-11560-14140-3 | "Beyond the general comments." |
---|
subtitle-14140-18680-4 | "Here are some examples, from past learners." |
---|
subtitle-19370-27500-5 | "Here's an example of a PVP, a Partnership Value Proposal: "to help preserve and promote" |
---|
subtitle-27500-33800-6 | "Examplian built heritage values, and allow people to access free knowledge about such" |
---|
subtitle-33800-39950-7 | "heritage, while enriching Wikimedia content" – we have two goals here: Preserve and" |
---|
subtitle-39950-44120-8 | "promote heritage values, and enriching Wikimedia content." |
---|
subtitle-44120-47080-9 | "So we've already expressed two benefits." |
---|
subtitle-47080-53420-10 | "– "Wikimedia Examplia would provide at no cost assistance to upload, categorize, and" |
---|
subtitle-53420-58130-11 | "place images and articles provided by partner under a Creative Commons Attribution" |
---|
subtitle-58130-59620-12 | "Share-Alike license." |
---|
subtitle-59620-65540-13 | "Wikimedia Examplia will also organize an article writing and improving contest about" |
---|
subtitle-65540-70670-14 | "heritage buildings managed or renovated by partner to supply more information to the" |
---|
subtitle-70670-76250-15 | "general public, while partner would provide related information about the renovation" |
---|
subtitle-76250-84490-16 | "process in data or text to be used as sources for the article in question." So it's" |
---|
subtitle-84490-87670-17 | "a long paragraph, but it hits everything we need." |
---|
subtitle-88450-95830-18 | "It expresses the value of the proposed partnership in terms of what each partner" |
---|
subtitle-95830-101110-19 | "would do, invest, and also the benefit to each partner." |
---|
subtitle-101530-104710-20 | "So this is a good Partnership Value Proposal." |
---|
subtitle-106990-114580-21 | "Here are a couple of other examples, and this one demonstrates the difference between" |
---|
subtitle-114790-122560-22 | "our private research findings that we discussed in a previous section and the" |
---|
subtitle-122560-127660-23 | "Partnership Value Proposal that we actually express to the partner." |
---|
subtitle-127900-135160-24 | "Remember that previously we've seen this example of a nonprofit that is Christian." |
---|
subtitle-135360-142360-25 | "It's an ecological conservation nonprofit, but its first foremost value is that they are" |
---|
subtitle-142360-148090-26 | "Christians and they believe that this conservation work is part of their religious" |
---|
subtitle-148090-150160-27 | "duty and their worship." |
---|
subtitle-151720-157060-28 | "So remember I said that this was an important thing to note in our research" |
---|
subtitle-157060-160330-29 | "findings. It's an important thing to understand about the partner." |
---|
subtitle-160360-166840-30 | "However, the learner that submitted this partnership proposal, let's read it: "We will" |
---|
subtitle-166840-174160-31 | "train the partner on how to digitize the ecological system created by God through" |
---|
subtitle-174160-178630-32 | "certain activities. When this is done, volunteers or community members would acquire" |
---|
subtitle-178630-185140-33 | "the necessary skills to increase visibility of God's given ecology through advocacy on" |
---|
subtitle-185140-194960-34 | "Wikipedia and its sister projects." So, I did tell you to use your partner's language" |
---|
subtitle-195410-199820-35 | "to address your partner's priorities, etc.." |
---|
subtitle-200480-206490-36 | "However, this partnership proposal is problematic." |
---|
subtitle-207210-208560-37 | "Why is it problematic?" |
---|
subtitle-209040-213390-38 | "I'm inviting you to ask yourselves in this box on the right." |
---|
subtitle-213810-218340-39 | "What does this imply about you, when you tell your partner we will teach you how to" |
---|
subtitle-218340-221520-40 | "increase the visibility of God's given ecology, etc.." |
---|
subtitle-222350-232100-41 | "You are implying that you are on board with their Christian perspective on their work," |
---|
subtitle-232100-234110-42 | "which is fine. And maybe you are." |
---|
subtitle-235150-238960-43 | "But it implies that your entire group is." |
---|
subtitle-239840-241880-44 | "And that may not be the case." |
---|
subtitle-241880-245540-45 | "And even if it is the case today, it may not be the case tomorrow." |
---|
subtitle-245630-251480-46 | "Maybe some people join you and they don't share this particular Christian view." |
---|
subtitle-252440-260660-47 | "And even more importantly, it implies this text implies that Wikipedia as a whole shares" |
---|
subtitle-260660-263420-48 | "this view or even tolerates this view." |
---|
subtitle-263540-265400-49 | "And that is not the case." |
---|
subtitle-266090-270940-50 | "You would not be able to make such a statement stick on Wikipedia." |
---|
subtitle-271760-279650-51 | "Wikipedia deals in facts and is neutral about faith, but it declines to describe" |
---|
subtitle-280100-283610-52 | "factual matters in faith-based terms." |
---|
subtitle-284720-293060-53 | "And so at most, Wikipedia will represent the fact that certain people or certain groups" |
---|
subtitle-293060-294860-54 | "hold certain views." |
---|
subtitle-295100-302570-55 | "But it would not describe the actual world, the actual ecological system in faith-based" |
---|
subtitle-302570-305450-56 | "terms as facts." |
---|
subtitle-305780-310430-57 | "Only as attributed beliefs to certain individuals or groups." |
---|
subtitle-310430-319130-58 | "And so, creating this Partnership Value Proposal sets our partner up for failure, or" |
---|
subtitle-319130-324620-59 | "for a misunderstanding, or for a nasty encounter with Wikipedia norms." |
---|
subtitle-324830-331640-60 | "Because if they were to try to develop content on Wikipedia or even on Commons" |
---|
subtitle-332450-337160-61 | "through this lens, they would meet resistance and they would be reverted, etc.." |
---|
subtitle-338330-345350-62 | "So this is an example of how, even though our research finding should indeed have" |
---|
subtitle-346700-352490-63 | "expressed very prominently, this organization is Christian, that's what" |
---|
subtitle-352490-353770-64 | "matters to them, etc." |
---|
subtitle-353780-362420-65 | "That's great. But if we are to partner with this organization, we have to find an" |
---|
subtitle-362420-369080-66 | "overlap, an area where our goals, that are different, their goals are faith-based, their" |
---|
subtitle-369080-372680-67 | "goals are to increase visibility of God's given ecology, etc." |
---|
subtitle-372860-379130-68 | "and our goals are different, they are to collect neutral factual content and images," |
---|
subtitle-379130-385940-69 | "etc. If we can find the narrow overlap that is possible between these goals – and there" |
---|
subtitle-385940-387110-70 | "is such an overlap." |
---|
subtitle-387110-394550-71 | "For example, maybe this group does work in an area geographically that is under-covered" |
---|
subtitle-394550-399860-72 | "on Commons and they can just take pictures of nature, of their conservation efforts," |
---|
subtitle-400640-402410-73 | "that we could use on Commons." |
---|
subtitle-402410-407990-74 | "And it doesn't matter that they did this, from their perspective, as part of their" |
---|
subtitle-408560-410270-75 | "faith, as part of their worship." |
---|
subtitle-410270-415580-76 | "Doesn't matter. The images are perfectly usable for our encyclopedic needs." |
---|
subtitle-416270-423260-77 | "So we can find a way to align our interests and our goals, at least in some narrow" |
---|
subtitle-423260-432230-78 | "overlap. But something like this, like signing on to their faith-based view as a" |
---|
subtitle-432230-434360-79 | "Wikimedia group, as distinct from as individuals." |
---|
subtitle-435290-440690-80 | "I mean, you as an individual Wikipedian can certainly be a member of this of this group" |
---|
subtitle-440690-445640-81 | "and share completely in their work, including their view of this work." |
---|
subtitle-446060-453710-82 | "But as a Wikimedia organization, we would do well to be careful to create the partnership" |
---|
subtitle-453710-458750-83 | "on a basis that's actually acceptable to Wikimedia as a whole." |
---|
subtitle-458750-461960-84 | "And remember that, to your partner, you are Wikipedia." |
---|
subtitle-462830-467690-85 | "They don't know, statistically, they probably don't know other Wikipedians." |
---|
subtitle-467690-472430-86 | "From their perspective, you are Wikipedia, you speak for Wikipedia, even though we know" |
---|
subtitle-472430-473590-87 | "that's not true." |
---|
subtitle-473590-481340-88 | "And we need to give our partner the benefit of the best advice about Wikimedia and" |
---|
subtitle-481340-488450-89 | "Wikipedia. The best advice about how to do well, how to succeed in contributing content" |
---|
subtitle-488450-490580-90 | "and value to Wikipedia." |
---|
subtitle-490580-495290-91 | "So this is not a good example of a Partnership Value Proposal." |
---|
subtitle-495290-505250-92 | "It certainly discusses benefits, but it actually crosses a line in how much" |
---|
subtitle-505250-507620-93 | "it identifies with the partner." |
---|
subtitle-508550-512570-94 | "To the point that it is making promises that it cannot keep." |
---|
subtitle-513630-518170-95 | "That's the problem. So I wanted to use this opportunity." |
---|
subtitle-518890-520750-96 | "I had this example come up." |
---|
subtitle-521140-524920-97 | "Use this opportunity to also give you a negative example." |
---|
subtitle-526030-531980-98 | "The second example on this page, completely different PVP, of course." |
---|
subtitle-531980-536160-99 | "Here it's a partner that is interested in Romanesque art." |
---|
subtitle-536170-542020-100 | "So the PVP is "to disseminate and offer society better information about Romanesque" |
---|
subtitle-542020-544800-101 | "art in the province of whatever." |
---|
subtitle-544800-548770-102 | "Wikimedia Examplia would provide training and coordination for people interested in" |
---|
subtitle-548770-551620-103 | "collaborating in the improvement of Wikipedia content." |
---|
subtitle-551950-558550-104 | "And the Partner Foundation would provide venues for training sessions, heritage images" |
---|
subtitle-558550-567310-105 | "and publicity." The benefit to the partner is not quite stated here explicitly, but" |
---|
subtitle-567580-574060-106 | "ostensibly that foundation is interested in the improvement of Wikipedia content about" |
---|
subtitle-574060-577150-107 | "Romanesque art, and so that's the benefit to them as well." |
---|
subtitle-578240-583250-108 | "And of course we Wikimedia are interested in improving content about Romanesque art, just" |
---|
subtitle-583250-586940-109 | "as we are interested in improving content about snails or airplanes." |
---|
subtitle-587150-588470-110 | "We're interested in improving all the content." |
---|
subtitle-588920-592280-111 | "So absolutely a benefit to us as well." |
---|
subtitle-593150-599960-112 | "The third example here, "library will tie up with the Wikimedia Foundation to access the" |
---|
subtitle-599960-602090-113 | "vast repository of knowledge." |
---|
subtitle-602210-609590-114 | "The Foundation will hold frequent workshops." This is not a good Partnership Value Proposal" |
---|
subtitle-609860-613760-115 | "because it is far too vague, and also incorrect." |
---|
subtitle-616460-620090-116 | "This person who wrote this, the learner who wrote this, is representing a particular" |
---|
subtitle-620090-626120-117 | "group. They are not representing the Wikimedia Foundation, and we must not mislead" |
---|
subtitle-626150-630530-118 | "our prospective partners to think that they would be partnering with the Wikimedia" |
---|
subtitle-630530-635360-119 | "Foundation, when in fact they will be partnering with our little user group or our" |
---|
subtitle-635360-637730-120 | "big chapter, but not the Wikimedia Foundation." |
---|
subtitle-638720-642800-121 | "Only the Wikimedia Foundation, people who actually work for the Wikimedia Foundation," |
---|
subtitle-643580-646310-122 | "can commit the Wikimedia Foundation to a partnership." |
---|
subtitle-647510-649610-123 | "So that's the point." |
---|
subtitle-649610-653180-124 | "I'm using this negative example to bring up that important point." |
---|
subtitle-653180-658400-125 | "It's important to make sure your partner understands who you are, which is why we have" |
---|
subtitle-658400-661880-126 | "self introductions and who they will be partnering with." |
---|
subtitle-661880-666110-127 | "They're not partnering with the Wikimedia Foundation, nor are they partnering with" |
---|
subtitle-666110-670040-128 | "Wikipedia. As we know, Wikipedia is a wiki site." |
---|
subtitle-670370-672050-129 | "It cannot partner with anything." |
---|
subtitle-672350-676370-130 | "They're partnering with you, with your group or affiliate or chapter, whether you are a" |
---|
subtitle-676370-677690-131 | "legal entity or not." |
---|
subtitle-677690-679100-132 | "They're partnering with you." |
---|
subtitle-685250-686870-133 | "That's the other example here." |
---|
subtitle-687260-693860-134 | "Here's another PVP "to help build more diverse, inclusive and plural online" |
---|
subtitle-693860-699410-135 | "ecosystem and society, as well as enhance the content about minority groups on the" |
---|
subtitle-699410-702650-136 | "Wikimedia platforms produced by minority groups." |
---|
subtitle-704180-711200-137 | "The wiki group so-and-so would provide at no cost to the so-and-so Museum of Art, training" |
---|
subtitle-711200-716630-138 | "for employees and register visitors, preferably from minority groups, interested" |
---|
subtitle-716630-721280-139 | "in learning and improving Wikipedia articles as volunteers in a series of free training" |
---|
subtitle-721280-722410-140 | "events, etc., etc." |
---|
subtitle-722450-726640-141 | "focused on content about women, people of color and art." |
---|
subtitle-726650-731270-142 | "The museum would provide the space, food, social media posts and equipment for the" |
---|
subtitle-731270-738320-143 | "participants." So this is a good PVP; it lists benefits to the museum." |
---|
subtitle-738320-743300-144 | "Presumably the museum cares about a more diverse, inclusive, and plural online" |
---|
subtitle-743300-744710-145 | "ecosystem and society." |
---|
subtitle-744710-752450-146 | "Presumably that's taken from somewhere in the museum's own goals or plans or mission" |
---|
subtitle-752720-756760-147 | "and enhance the content about minority groups on the Wikimedia platforms." |
---|
subtitle-756770-759440-148 | "That's, of course, something we care about." |
---|
subtitle-759440-765410-149 | "And this group, this PVP also stresses "enhance the content about minority groups" |
---|
subtitle-765410-767570-150 | "produced by minority groups"." |
---|
subtitle-767570-773750-151 | "In other words, it seeks to address not just the content gap about minority groups, but" |
---|
subtitle-773750-776300-152 | "also the participation gap." |
---|
subtitle-777080-779360-153 | "The gap in who produces knowledge." |
---|
subtitle-779360-784160-154 | "And we've already seen an example of this in an earlier section, where we said something" |
---|
subtitle-784160-789920-155 | "like "most of the content about Examplia is not written by people from Examplia"." |
---|
subtitle-789920-790970-156 | "Remember that example?" |
---|
subtitle-793320-799080-157 | "And this PVP, of course, says very concretely what will happen, what each side" |
---|
subtitle-799080-804450-158 | "will provide. The Wikimedia group will provide training and the museum will provide" |
---|
subtitle-804780-806910-159 | "the space, the food facilities, equipment, etc.." |
---|
subtitle-807810-811380-160 | "It's very clear and a good PVP." |
---|