Talk:Wiki Loves the Olympics 2018
Add a new sports person's nameEdit
Olympic symbols - articleEdit
Hi. I created an article about the Olympic symbols on Ukrainian Wikipedia, it mentions the Winter Olympic Games, but it is not directly connected with them. Is it possible to write articles like this? Or should the articles be linked directly to the Winter Olympic Games? Thank you in advance for your reply.WayDong (talk) 1:52, 10 February 2018 (UTC)
Free photos sourceEdit
There were some good sources at the Rio Games that provided photos we could use in articles, but I have not seen that yet for these Olympics. Have you all noticed any sources that are publishing photos under a license we can use? Kees08 (talk) 20:26, 11 February 2018 (UTC)
Translation to Hindi WikipediaEdit
Conflict around scoringEdit
Hi @Millars and Vanbasten 23:. We have a conflict around scoring system of Wiki Loves the Olympics in the Ukrainian Wikipedia. The issue concerns articles about individual events like uk:Ковзанярський спорт на зимових Олімпійських іграх 2018 — 3000 метрів (жінки). A real situation that happened is the following:
- User A creates a stub before the event. The stub is 2 KB long and has very basic information like infobox, date, time, venue, competition and distance. The user would get +3 points (1 new and 2 KB), he participates in the contest but is not that motivated to win, and has not enough time to add live results.
- User B adds an empty results table. The table is long, the user would get 4 points (4 KB) for a very small effort. The user does not participate in the contest.
- User C wants to add results. The total article (infobox + introduction + completed results table) would be 12 KB long. It is clear his works is the most time-consuming among the three. If the article were new, he would have received +13 points (1 new and 12 KB). However, a stub with an empty table already exists, thus he receives only 6 points (+6 KB). He is very interested in the contest and wants to win, and has a lot of time to add live results.
The problem is that user C is not willing to add results to the existing article because he would get less than a half of points he would have received for a new one (6 instead of 13). Because of this there is a conflict between users A and C: C insists on deletion of stubs without results (to get more points), while A insists that stubs do not violate rules as, well, they are stubs. The conflict became really heated within the last two days and split the community between "stubs are good/delete the stubs" and "contests are good/ban this contest" (I think people with such views exist in all communities). What are your thoughts about it? — NickK (talk) 14:13, 15 February 2018 (UTC)
- Hi NickK and thanks for your time. I usually participate in several competitions during a year, sometimes I win, and sometimes I do not. But I always have one thing clear. If I am going to win, I have to find articles that provide me many points and, of course, contribute to the project. If you want to add points, you have a million options, articles, references and tables to include. I think he has to look strategies and not problems with other users. The user A does his job well, because if nobody came behind, at least there is something in the article. These contests are trying to motivate users who do not have a specific theme to edit, I think that they are important at a certain time like the current one, because readers will search those articles. The prizes are secondary, but if someone is very motivated, he has to be as productive as possible. Surely the first ones in the tournament will be those that have included articles with many tables, because these increase the code a lot... --Vanbasten 23 (talk) 15:11, 15 February 2018 (UTC)
Points and articlesEdit
I want to say that the organizers will check the points at the end of the contest. In addition, remember that the contest is for Wikipedia articles about Winter Olympics and Paralympics (Wikidata items are welcome, but don't provide points, and the same for Summer Olympics). --Millars (talk) 00:17, 27 February 2018 (UTC)
Summer Paralympics and some other thingsEdit
Hello. It's my first Wiki Competition, so I have a lot of questions: 1) In the rules, there is information, that this contest is for Wikipedia articles about Winter Olympics and Paralympics, but I did't understand: is it just about winter Paralympics or articles about summer Paralympics also can be counted? 2) Can I count points, if I wrote about some general topics, that connect with winter Oplympics just partly, like "National Biathlon Team of Ukraine" or "National Olympic Committee of Ukraine"/ "relay race (biathlon)"? 3) If the article about Topic A is very short, almost incorrect, complecated, is it better to write new one with this topic or just change info? 4) If I wrote some new information about Paralympics sportsman, but it's smaller than 1000 symbols, should I count it like 2 points, or not? I will be grateful to read the anwers soon. Rina.sl (talk) 21:40, 12 March 2018 (UTC)Rina.sl
- Hello. Welcome and enjoy the contest. I'll answer you your questions:
- When I wrote "Wikipedia articles about Winter Olympics and Paralympics" I meaned Winter for both kind of competition. How should I write it to put it clearer?
- There should be olny an article per topic. So it is better to fix and complete the information. One option is to write from zero, and then merge the content.
- Thanks to you for participating and sorry for the delay Rina.sl. --Millars (talk) 09:20, 14 March 2018 (UTC)
Youth Olympic GamesEdit
- I'm sorry because I did not see your question. I think you asked about Youth Olympic Games? We did not consider that in this edition. But we are open to change and improve things for a maybe future edition. --Millars (talk) 21:34, 3 April 2018 (UTC)
- We are checking all articles and points. We are very happy because there are a lot of articles, but this means also a lot of work. We'll try to have them by April 15. --Millars (talk) 21:33, 3 April 2018 (UTC)
- Congratulations to the winners and all participants. And thanks for @Millars: and other organizers --Alaa :)..! 05:41, 19 April 2018 (UTC)