Open main menu

Requests for comment/Travel Guide/Commenters composition

Note: it's usually required on Meta-Wiki, for serious votes like stewards elections, that the voter's account is linked to the local accounts either via SUL merged account or by reciprocated linking of userpages (of course, added while logged in).

WikiTravel administratorsEdit

EnglishEdit

UnverifiedEdit

  1. Aude admin link to Wikipedia account; link to wikitravel; sul
  2. Atsirlin
  3. Bill-on-the-Hill
  4. Cacahuate
  5. Cardboardbird
  6. CJensen
  7. Denisyurkin
  8. DerFussi
  9. Digr
  10. Elgaard
  11. Evan
  12. Flip666
  13. Gentenaar
  14. Globe-trotter
  15. Gorilla Jones
  16. Ikan Kekek
  17. Inas
  18. Jc8136
  19. Joelf
  20. Jonboy
  21. Jpatokal
  22. LtPowers
  23. Maj
  24. Mark
  25. NJR ZA
  26. OldPine
  27. Pashley
  28. Quirk
  29. Ravikiran r
  30. Rein N.
  31. Riggwelter
  32. Sapphire
  33. Sergey kudryavtsev
  34. Sertmann
  35. Shaund
  36. Texugo
  37. Trsqr
  38. Vidimian
  39. Vlad
  40. Wrh2
  41. Yann

All commentersEdit

Full list taken from [1] (CSV; gives urlencoded usernames, which accounts for some weirdness following). The following from a stupid wgetting of all the Special:CentralAuth/.

  • About 70 IPs and 30 more voters without a global account (pre-2008 users who never cared about merging their accounts).
Requests for comment/Travel Guide/Commenters composition
  1. 108.80.181.47
  2. 110.174.146.99
  3. 121.203.77.26
  4. 121.218.143.50
  5. 122.162.152.234
  6. 122.53.79.163
  7. 128.72.151.88
  8. 130.89.224.159
  9. 134.60.50.127
  10. 137.248.1.25
  11. 141.116.212.23
  12. 142.162.108.223
  13. 174.95.254.215
  14. 178.73.50.7
  15. 184.174.172.170
  16. 192.204.67.212
  17. 192.204.70.114
  18. 192.204.79.85
  19. 194.113.59.80
  20. 194.138.39.55
  21. 2001:558:FE21:1:69:252:204:68
  22. 204.239.148.2
  23. 212.182.104.44
  24. 213.114.74.64
  25. 216.38.130.166
  26. 217.209.172.253
  27. 217.245.252.81
  28. 219.41.204.2
  29. 2.225.116.57
  30. 24.231.86.240
  31. 24.24.230.95
  32. 24.66.14.92
  33. 24.7.59.158
  34. 27.32.253.217
  35. 41.145.142.31
  36. 41.243.200.45
  37. 64.183.42.67
  38. 67.121.110.182
  39. 68.173.113.106
  40. 70.27.237.45
  41. 71.118.174.102
  42. 71.125.51.43
  43. 74.73.104.81
  44. 76.167.153.64
  45. 76.171.30.1
  46. 76.95.1.130
  47. 79.180.173.100
  48. 79.25.153.125
  49. 79.52.12.102
  50. 79.90.237.161
  51. 81.105.63.121
  52. 83.250.92.82
  53. 83.254.117.34
  54. 84.185.15.19
  55. 84.41.86.38
  56. 84.62.135.56
  57. 84.73.68.231
  58. 86.129.5.72
  59. 86.29.7.196
  60. 86.54.83.147
  61. 88.176.129.199
  62. 88.253.158.251
  63. 91.145.84.241
  64. 92.73.192.149
  65. 92.96.49.28
  66. 93.130.145.132
  67. 95.176.66.71
  68. 98.154.135.180
  69. 98.209.136.52
  70. Arcy
  71. Avriette
  72. BambooBeast
  73. Bemoeial
  74. Berek
  75. Billdanbury
  76. Denis_Yurkin
  77. Dirk_Schmidt
  78. Duval
  79. Eco84
  80. ElfQrin
  81. Elgaard
  82. Exec8
  83. Flip666
  84. Genium
  85. Gorilla_Jones
  86. Hans-Jürgen_Hübner
  87. Hernaldo
  88. History2007
  89. Hubertl
  90. J1729
  91. Jdlh
  92. Justme2
  93. L-Bit
  94. MarkJaroski
  95. Pashley
  96. Paulv
  97. Ravikiran_r
  98. Schlaier
  99. Slaven_Kosanovic
  100. Srml
  101. Sterio
  102. Stilfehler
  103. TarzanASG
  104. Texugo
  105. Valmi
  106. Vlad
  107. W._Frank
  • 598 merged accounts with varying levels of activity, of which 115 with less that 600 global edits (standard minimum e.g. for Stewards elections 2010). What follows with an even sillier grep -Eo "Total editcount:[^<]+" * | sed "s/Total editcount:<\/strong>//".
  • Of those about 218 users with no SUL or less than 600 global edits, 114 were in support of the RfC and 41 against.
  • The RfC made Meta earn a lot of new users: 315 out of 596 have less than 10 edits. Non-merged accounts should be considered too, but they are mostly old users. grep -Eo '[^"]+ contributions? on meta.wikimedia.org' * | sed -E "s/contributions? on meta.wikimedia.org//".
  • Among those users with less than 10 Meta-Wiki edits, 174 were for and 46 against; among those who lacked either SUL, 600 global edits or 10 local edits (non veteran Meta-Wiki voters?), 228 were for and 63 against.