Grants talk:Programs/Wikimedia Community Fund/Rapid Fund/Wikisource Minangkabau (ID: 22363551)

Endorsment from Ardzun (talk)

I support this grant, because there are so many manuscripts written in Minangkabau land and some of them written in Minangkabau language. I think, Minangkabau need their own Wikisource to facilitate their language. --Ardzun (talk) 14:48, 26 October 2023 (UTC)

Endorsment from Apriadi ap (talk)

many of local languages ​​in Indonesia and having a collection of books with a diversity of cultural entities, Minangkabau is one of the most active in the Wikimedia project and has contributed a lot in content development, I support Minangkabau Wikisource to leave the incubator and add to the collective treasures of wiki projects in Indonesia .

--Apriadi ap (talk) 03:03, 2 November 2023 (UTC)

Endorsment from Empat Tilda (talk)

-- sangat menarik untuk dapat menghadirkan berbagai bahasa dalam wikisource, untuk menjadikan koleksi digital yang semakin beragam. untuk budget sebesar itu saran saya memakai manajer proyek untuk mengarsipkan bukti dan keuangan. Kak nisa bisa fokus dalam terselenggaranya beberapa acara yang sudah dikonsepkan. semaaaaaaangkaaaaaaa, semangat kakaaaaaaakkk Empat Tilda (talk) 07:04, 2 November 2023 (UTC)

Endorsment from Mrifqis713 (talk)

--Mrifqis713 (talk) 13:09, 10 November 2023 (UTC)

Not funded / Tidak didanai

Hello sathira15, we appreciate your efforts to put down this proposal and your willingness to activate the Wikisource Minangkabau. However, after reviewing your proposal, we made a decision to not fund it. Here are the main reasons for our decision:

• The requested budget is not aligned with the proposed impact. Almost half of the project expenses are for the staff costs and there are proposed staff positions that are not directly related to the project impact.
• Additionally, we considered the fact that the Wikisource Minangkabau is currently inactive and that the project will result in 5 manuscripts digitized. The need for digitizing these manuscripts is also not well presented in the proposal.
• Finally, the proposal seems to be indirectly connected to Wikimedia Indonesia and their activities. However, the proposal doesn't demonstrate the effort to use some of Wikimedia Indonesia resources to digitize the manuscripts but instead requests additional funds to do the work.

(diterjemahkan melalui DeepL)

Halo sathira15, kami menghargai usaha Anda untuk mengajukan proposal ini dan kesediaan Anda untuk mengaktifkan Wikisource Minangkabau. Namun, setelah meninjau proposal Anda, kami memutuskan untuk tidak mendanainya. Berikut adalah alasan utama dari keputusan kami:

• Anggaran yang diminta tidak sesuai dengan dampak yang diusulkan. Hampir setengah dari biaya proyek adalah untuk biaya staf dan ada posisi staf yang diusulkan yang tidak terkait langsung dengan dampak proyek.
• Selain itu, kami mempertimbangkan fakta bahwa Wikisource Minangkabau saat ini tidak aktif dan proyek ini akan menghasilkan 5 naskah yang akan didigitalkan. Kebutuhan untuk mendigitalkan naskah-naskah ini juga tidak dipaparkan dengan baik di dalam proposal.
• Terakhir, proposal tersebut tampaknya secara tidak langsung berhubungan dengan Wikimedia Indonesia dan kegiatan-kegiatan mereka. Namun, proposal tersebut tidak menunjukkan upaya untuk menggunakan beberapa sumber daya Wikimedia Indonesia untuk mendigitalkan manuskrip, melainkan meminta dana tambahan untuk melakukan pekerjaan tersebut. --DSaroyan (WMF) (talk) 10:41, 29 November 2023 (UTC)