User talk:BDavis (WMF)/Archives/2014
 | Please do not post any new comments on this page. This is a discussion archive first created in 2014, although the comments contained were likely posted before and after this date. See current discussion or the archives index. |
talk: A system for reviewing funding requests.
A system for reviewing funding requests
- Public URL
- https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Google_Summer_of_Code_2014#A_system_for_reviewing_funding_requests
- Announcement
- http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/wikitech-l/2014-March/075384.html
Name and contact information
- Name
- Rahul Mishra.
- priyrahulmishra AT gmail DOT com
- IRC or IM networks/handle(s)
- rahulmishra on Freenode
- Blog
- http://rahulxarvis.blogspot.in/
- Twitter handle
- mishra_2291
- Github
- https://github.com/Rahul91/
- Location
- Kolkata, India.
- Time zone
- UTC + 5:30 hours IST
- Typical working hours
- 1800 IST - 0000 IST(weekdays), 1100 IST - 1500 IST & 2000 IST - 0100 IST
Synopsis
Wikimedia Foundation Grantmaking aims at increasing the quantity, quality, diversity, and reach of free knowledge. Wikimedia Grantmaking is a collaboration between grantees, WMF staff, volunteer committees, and Wikimedians from across the globe.
Individual Engagement Grants support Wikimedians to complete projects that benefit the Wikimedia movement. It focus is on experimentation for online impact. The goal of this project is to either create or adapt a free and open source review system for funding requests, applicable to Individual Engagement Grants, conference scholarships, and similar programs. Individual Engagement Grants review process currently uses an ad hoc scoring system involving Google Forms to collect input from reviewers, which is unwieldy and won't scale well as the number of proposals to review increases. Also findings from initial investigations suggests a need for a new scoring tool.
There are basically four core user of this reviewing system, they being.
| Role | Domain of Work / Responsibilities |
|---|---|
| As an administrator of the grant review system | To create new grant campaigns, consisting
|
| As a grant administrator or reviewer | To mark grant applications as eligible or ineligible |
| As a grant reviewer | To score a grant application on multiple dimensions |
| As a grant provider or administrator | To view reports on the aggregate reviewer scores for grant applications and to share results and to and select applications to fund. |
In a nutshell the system will allow an administrator to specify the criteria by which the grants will be judged. A defined set of reviewers will then score and comment on each application. Once this scoring is complete, the system will average the scores of all of the reviewers and apply the relative importance values specified by the administrator to produce a report showing how each proposal has been assessed.
- Benefits
- The reviewing system will be more efficient than the current process, which is unwieldy and does not suits large scale implementation.
- The reviewing can be done on multi-dimensional criteria, specified by the admins.
- The system will greatly aid the grantmakers in the selection process for funding requests.
- Possible mentors
- Siko Bouterse (Grantmaking), Bryan Davis (Platform Engineering), Dan Garry (Product/Platform Engineering)
Deliverables
- A simple, user-friendly Dashboard for Admininstator, Reviwer and Grant Provider.
- A system that allows multiple reviewers to score IEG proposals, on multi-dimensional criteria as defined by admins.
- A system flexible enough to be reused for other types of applications like event scholarships, etc later on.
- A system that outputs the total fund requested and total fund granted.
Participation
Project Plan
I have divided the entire project in three major phases :
- Preparation Phase
* Involves the understanding of the project in depth, and polishing the concepts of PHP and mysql. * Read previous project Documentation, if any. * Establishing proper co-ordination with project mentors.
- Development Phase
* Develop the basic Dashboard for Administrators, Reviewers, and Grant Providers. * Working on database connectivity portion. * Working on table design and there attributes, as required. * Improve the Dashboard and discuss the with mentors. * Improve the Database tables, and there attributes, and discuss it with mentors. * Discuss with the mentors for the potential improvements in the project.
- Testing Phase
* Review all the functionalities of the Dashboard and Database. * Testing all the functionalities. * Fixing of bug, if found. * Work on final Documentation part.
Timeline
| Duration | Task |
|---|---|
| April 22 - May 18 | Preparation Phase Complete |
| May 19 | Official Begining of GSoc-2014 Coding |
| May 19 - May 25 | Develop the basic Dashboard for Administrators, Reviewers, and Grant Providers. |
| May 26 - June 2 | Working on database connectivity portion. |
| June 3- June 10 | Working on table design and there attributes, as required. |
| June 11 - June 22 | Improve the Dashboard and discuss the with mentors. |
| June 23 | Submit Mid term Evaluations |
| June 24 - July 14 | Improve the Dashboard, and improve the Database part, and discuss it with mentors. Also discussing the potential improvements in the project. |
| June 15 | Development Phase Complete |
| July 16 - July 26 | Review/Testing all the functionalities of the Dashboard and Database. |
| July 27 - Aug 5 | Fixing bug, if found. |
| Aug 5 - Aug 12 | Final Documentation of the project. |
| Aug 12 | Testing Phase Complete |
| Aug 13 - Aug 18 | Project Complete, Submit for final evaluation. |
About me
I am Rahul Mishra,final year undergraduate and pursuing my B-Tech form Netaji Subhash Engineering College having majors Computer Sciences & Engineering. I mostly code in C and Java, along with these i am also comfortable in C++, python, Shell scripting, PHP, JavaScript, CSS and HTML. I have been using Free and Open Source Softwares, since last two years, and am completely familiar with things like Git, Github, Gerrit, IRC, mailing list and mail posting etc. My favourate subjects are Networking and Operating Systems. Currently i am working on Cryptography, implementation of SHA-1 to be specific, which is also my final year project. Apart from academics, i am very much interested in Robotics, specially Autonomous Robotics, i am also one of the Robotics Head at Phoenix. Also i am a member of Nixal, the Linux-User group of our college.
Link to my Userpage: Rahulmishra22
What drives me to contribute to this project, is my willingness to learn new and cool stuffs, i have always had some craving towards science & technology, particularly related to computers. Also i want to start contributing to open source, and mediawiki is a perfect platform for me. I like the philosophy of FOSS and want to contribute in some way or other.
- Education completed or in progress
- In Progress, currently in Final Year.
- How did you hear about this program?
I have heard about the program from my college friends and batchmates.
- Will you have any other time commitments, such as school work, another job, planned vacation, etc., during the duration of the program?
I will be having my regular college till May, just that and else i have no time constraints and i am sure i can manage my regular college and examinations without having any effect on this program.
- We advise all candidates eligible to Google Summer of Code and FOSS Outreach Program for Women to apply for both programs. Are you planning to apply to both programs and, if so, with what organization(s)?
Only GSoC.
Past experience
- Please describe your experience with any other FOSS projects as a user and as a contributor
This will be my first experience with FOSS project as a contributer,so i may fall behind in experience but i have worked in projects involving team and i know what it really takes to be working as a team . Before i have always used FOSS and evaluated it as an end user.
- What project(s) are you interested in (these can be in the same or different organizations)?
I am very new to mediawiki in general, but in this short span of time i have tried fixing
The experience was exhilarating and thrilling, working and fixing under some time constraint was the biggest challange, but in last i succeeded in my endavour. Link to my gerrit account.
Any other info
Following are the Dashboards that can be used by Reviewers :
| name | description | approved? | requested amount | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grants:IEG/Map atlas | a short description from the idea page (first template) | not scored yet | $1,000 | |
| Grants:IEG/Gadget to do Foos and Bars | a short description from the idea page (first template) | yes | $10,000 | should talk to candidate about X |
| Total (Tools) | Total amount you funded. | $10,000 | 1 scored, 1 not yet |
Following can be the Dashboards that can be used by Grant Reviewers :
| name | description | Score | requested amount | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grants:IEG/Map atlas | a short description from the idea page (first template) | not done | $1,000 | |
| Grants:IEG/Gadget to do Foos and Bars | a short description from the idea page (first template) |
|
$10,000 | should talk to candidate about X |
| Total (Tools) | Total amount you funded. | $10,000 | 1 scored, 1 not yet |
Following can be the Dashboards that can be used by Grant Provider :
| name | description | approved? | Score | requested amount | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grants:IEG/Map atlas | a short description from the idea page (first template) | not approved yet | not scored yet | $1,000 | |
| Grants:IEG/Gadget to do Foos and Bars | a short description from the idea page (first template) | yes |
|
$10,000 | should talk to candidate about X |
| Total (Tools) | Total amount you funded. | $10,000 | 1 scored, 1 not yet |
: Edited your talk page so that the previous content is within the topic. Kushal124 (talk) 17:39, 20 March 2014 (UTC)
GSOC Project Review
Hi Bryan
I am applying for GSOC Project with wikimedia. My project topic is : A system for reviewing funding requests. As you have been listed as one of the mentors , I would like to have your feedback on this proposal. Link : https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/User:Kushal124/A_system_for_reviewing_funding_requests_GSOC
This is an initial draft and I would complete this proposal today itself.
I hope to have you as my mentor for this project.
Thanks Kushal124 (talk) 17:42, 20 March 2014 (UTC)