Grants talk:Project/Whose Knowledge/Whose Knowledge?/Midpoint

Add discussion
Active discussions

DalitEdit

Working with dalits is nice. Environmentalist associations (or at least Legambiente) are also an ally in this regard. --Nemo 08:21, 11 June 2017 (UTC)

DuplicationEdit

Several paragraphs are repeated more than once across the report. This does not make reading very easy or pleasurable. --Nemo 08:24, 11 June 2017 (UTC)

Found sourcesEdit

Do I see correctly in the spreadsheet that, out of hundreds identified items, only 17 were matched with some source (even including Facebook posts and blogs)? This is worse than I expected: Dalits are a huge topic with plenty of literature (although not all of it may be good or cover every important aspect). If this method fails even to provide a comprehensive guide to the existing literature (at least for the weak spots of the Wikimedia projects content), it may be worth considering a different method. --Nemo 08:35, 11 June 2017 (UTC)

Spreadsheet archivalEdit

Since most of the work/output seems to be in the form of a Google Docs spreadsheet, which in addition to being proprietary is liable to suddenly vanish at some point, how do you plan to archive such material at the end of the work? Please at very least upload a PDF version to Wikimedia Commons. --Nemo 08:35, 11 June 2017 (UTC)

Return to "Project/Whose Knowledge/Whose Knowledge?/Midpoint" page.