File talk:Jordonswikilogo2 sm.png

I thought this would be an interesting idea. Sure, it's text, but I daresay the exclamation mark appears in most, if not all of the Wikipedia languages. (But then, I'm probably wrong.) Just an attempt at a simple, yet easily recognizeable symbol. --Jordon Kalilich, 2003-07-24

I think you need 3D glasses to view this logo.

This logo represents absolutely no content. It's good of you to come up with such a simplistic piece of art, nonetheless I think this is horrible. Anonymous.

This is rather silly. No offense, but its redundant. - user:zanimum

The symbol is easily recognized, but it isn't clear what it symbolizes in relation to Wikipedia. -- Stephen Gilbert 03:16 27 Jul 2003 (UTC)

At first I thought the exclamation mark would be a good idea, because it's international (see above), and it signifies (in a way) the spirit of Wikipedia. You come searching for something, and then - aha! - you find it. I also thought the tripled effect would be cool too. It looks like this logo isn't very popular, and I can see why. Therefore, I am withdrawing it from the contest. --Jordon Kalilich, 2003-07-27

Hey, at least you had a go! Take everything as constructive criticism and try again... you've got time. Who knows, the next time may be a winner! You can develop your skills, and even if you can't realise a concept you might have yet, you are thinking about a meaning before you start "putting pen to paper". This is a step ahead of a lot of other people, and a good way to approach any design brief, especially one as open as this. I'd love to see another submission from you! Neolux 03:48 31 Jul 2003 (UTC)

I've also submitted entries 13 and 23, if you want to see them. :) --Jordon Kalilich, 2003-07-31

Ah, sorry about that. I've commented on 23... good job! Neolux 19:50 31 Jul 2003 (UTC)